10 Shows to Watch if You Loved A Good Girl‘s Guide To Murder

After the massive success of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder on Netflix, crime drama enthusiasts scampered the OTT platforms to find similar shows. Based on Holly Jackson’s bestselling mystery trilogy of the same name, the show starring Wednesday actor EMMA Myers ticks off several boxes that make it a worthy watch.

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder follows the story of a 17-year-old aspiring detective, Pippa Fitz-Amobi (Myers) who embarks on a mission to find Andie Bell (India Lillie Davies). Meanwhile, Andie is presumed dead and her boyfriend, Sal (Rahul Pattni) is deemed to be her murderer.

The show premiered on the BBC in July and was released on Netflix on 1 August 2024. It was an instant hit among fans. If you enjoy shows that offer a blend of suspense and thrill in engaging ways, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder should definitely be on your watch list.

While we wait for Netflix to announce the second season, take a look at this list of best shows like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder on streaming platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, and more.

Review: Netflix-bound, BBC’s A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder Plays to the Chemistry of the Stars

Lifestyle

The Key Differences Between the Book and TV Show Adaptation of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

Lifestyle

10 best shows like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder and where to watch them

1. Riverdale (2017)

IMDb rating: 6.5
Where to watch: Netflix
No. of seasons: 7
Cast: KJ Apa, Lili Reinhart, Cole Sprouse and Camila Mendes

First on the list of shows like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is Netflix’s Riverdale. Based on the characters from the iconic Archie Comics, The CW drama centres around the lives of Archie (KJ Apa), Betty (Lili Reinhart), Veronica (Camila Mendes) and Jughead (Cole Sprouse) living in the quaint town called Riverdale.

They might seem like a normal bunch of teenagers (except, more stylish) but their lives turn upside down after the Mysterious death of a high school student, Jason Blossom. The show unravels the dirty secrets of the town held dearly by the older citizens under the pretence of protecting their kids.

Upon its release in 2017, Riverdale was an instant hit on Netflix. Every actor in the series was catapulted to success. However, as the series was stretched to seven seasons, fans started criticising the exhaustive plots and twists — from introducing a parallel universe called Rivervale to the Black Hood — that turned the show absurdly comical.

Watch here.

2. Veronica Mars (2004)

IMDb rating: 8.4
Where to watch: Prime Video
No. of seasons: 4
Cast: Kristen Bell, Teddy Dunn and Jason Dohring

The critically acclaimed series perfectly blends the elements of noir with teen drama. The four seasons of the show were highly praised for its witty writing, complex characters and engaging mysteries.

Set in the fictional town of Neptune, California, the series centres around a high school student-turned-investigator Veronica Mars (Kristen Bell), who embarks on a mission to unravel the mystery behind her best friend Lilly Kane’s (Amanda Seyfried) murder. Veronica takes up several side jobs as a private investigator while pursuing her primary goal.

Each season offers new adventures in the life of Veronica Mars. The sharp-witted teenager manages to uncover the truth while also trying to restore her family’s reputation. The twists and tragedies in the show will keep you on edge.

Watch here.

3. Cruel Summer (2021)

IMDb rating: 7.4
Where to watch: Prime Video
No. of seasons: 2
Cast: Chiara Aurelia and Olivia Holt

Calm down Swifties! This is not that Taylor Swift song. Cruel Summer is an American teen drama mystery thriller anthology that centres around two teenage girls in the mid-1990s.

The psychological thriller oscillates between the perspectives of Jeanette Turner (Chiara Aurelia) and Kate Wallis (Olivia Holt). Following the latter’s disappearance, Jeanette’s shocking transformation from an outcast to a popular girl raises suspicions. The first season explores the complexities of trauma as disturbing truths unravel.

The second season introduces a completely different storyline along with new characters. Set in the early 2000s, the sequel focuses on Megan Landry (Sadie Stanley) and Isabella LaRue’s (Lexi Underwood) unusual friendship. Like the first season, Cruel Summer 2 also shifts between timelines to expose hidden lies.

The drama was praised for its well-written characters and intriguing exploration of psychological themes.

Watch here.

4. Elite (2018)

IMDb rating: 7.2
Where to watch: Netflix
No. of seasons: 8
Cast: María Pedraza, Itzan Escamilla and Miguel Bernardeau

The Spanish teen drama garnered a huge international following, thanks to its intriguing plot and charming yet complex characters.

Set in Las Encinas, the fictional elite private school has become a war zone between the rich bratty kids and students from less privileged backgrounds. It centres around three students from the working class — Samuel (Itzan Escamilla), Nadia (Miguel Bernardeau) and Christian (Miguel Herrán) — who attend the Las Encinas after bagging scholarships.

While school is all about studying and making new friends, the stark difference between the two worlds existing within the walls of the elite school creates tension. Each season of the drama revolves around a Mysterious crime that leads to secrets being exposed and relationships getting ruined.

Watch here.

5. Yellowjackets (2021)

IMDb rating: 7.8
Where to watch: Netflix
No. of seasons: 2
Cast: Sophie Nélisse, Jasmin Savoy Brown and Sophie Thatcher

The praise-worthy psychological exploration in Yellowjackets perfectly combines elements of mystery, horror and survival.

The series follows the tragic plane crash carrying a high school girls’ soccer team. It alternates between two timelines of the victims of the crash. The first timeline shows the survivors of the crash trying to make it out alive in the wilderness. The other timeline shows present-day adult survivors dealing with the trauma of the tragedy.

The series sheds light on the human psyche when pushed to extremes. It plays with the themes of humanity, survival and the psychological scars that never heal. The element of mystery seamlessly intertwines with the depiction of horror and trauma.

Watch here.

6. Nancy Drew (2019)

IMDb rating: 6.7
Where to watch: JioCinema
No. of seasons: 4
Cast: Kennedy McMann

Based on the classic book series by Carolyn Keene, the show follows the titular character, Nancy Drew (Kennedy McMann), solving various mysteries.

After the death of her mother, Nancy Drew decides to put down her detective glasses indefinitely. However, the detective in her doesn’t die as she gets pulled towards a Mysterious murder in her hometown, Horseshoe Bay. While investigating the murder, Drew unearths the shocking secrets about her town.

Drew also learns about the dark secrets of her family. The series also adds a supernatural element, making the show intriguing to watch. The well-crafted narration as well as the complex characters earned praises from the critics and audiences alike.

Watch here.

7. One of Us Is Lying (2021)

IMDb rating: 6.9
Where to watch: Netflix
No. of seasons: 2
Cast: Mark McKenna and Annalisa Cochrane

Based on the novel by Karen M. McManus, One Of Us Is Lying centres around a group of five high school students in a detention room. The twist comes when only four students come out alive.

The series then dives deeper into the investigation of Simon’s (Mark McKenna) death. As the probe progresses, several secrets and revelations about the students’ lives are exposed. The psychological element in the series helps the viewers delve further into the lives of the surviving students who are now prime suspects.

Watch here.

8. Harlan Coben’s Shelter (2023)

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Harlan Coben (@harlancoben)

IMDb rating: 6.6
Where to watch: Prime Video
No. of seasons: 1
Cast: Jaden Michael, Constance Zimmer, Abby Corrigan, and Adrian Greensmith

Harlan Coben’s Shelter is based on the novel by Harlan Coben. It centres around Mickey Bolitar, a teenager reeling from his father’s death and his mother’s disappearance.

Following the tragic events, Mickey moves in with his aunt and joins a new school. Meanwhile, he decides to investigate his father’s death. He soon discovers the dark secrets of the seemingly peaceful community during his investigation.

The series touches upon themes like trauma, coping with a personal loss and navigating high school life. The twists and revelations in the story are intriguing enough to make you want to binge-watch the show like you did with A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.

Watch here.

9. The End of the F***ing World (2017)

IMDb rating: 8
Where to watch: Netflix
No. of seasons: 2
Cast: Jessica Barden and Alex Lawther

The End of the F***ing World offers a look into the endlessly bizarre and increasingly dangerous adventures of two troubled teenagers.

A 17-year-old James, (Alex Lawther) who believes he is a psychopath, meets Alyssa (Jessica Barden), a rebellious and bored teenager who wants to spice up her mundane life. Being the self-proclaimed psychopath, James decides to accompany Alyssa on a road trip and kill her later.

However, his plans come to an abrupt halt as the journey compels them to confront their issues while also dealing with various obstacles including questionable criminal activities. The series’ unique blend of dark humour and unconventional narrative style makes it a gripping show.

Watch here.

10. Twin Peaks (1990)

IMDb rating: 8
Where to watch: Paramount Plus, Amazon Prime Video
No. of seasons: 3
Cast: Kyle MacLachlan, Michael Ontkean and Mädchen Amick

Created by David Lynch and Mark Frost, the show has gained a cult classic status over the years, thanks to its unique blend of mystery and drama.

It follows the tragic event of the homecoming queen Laura Palmer’s (Sheryl Lee) murder in the quaint town of Twin Peaks. FBI agent Dale Cooper (Kyle MacLachlan) investigates the case and finds a series of unusual activities that compel him to question reality. His investigation leads him to unearth secrets of the town that were best kept hidden.

The drama also incorporates supernatural elements to create an enigmatic atmosphere for the viewers. The quirky characters in the series and the cryptic plot twists will not let you down.

Watch here.

(Header and feature image courtesy: A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder and Cruel Summer/ IMDb)

This story first appeared on Lifestyle Asia Hong Kong.