Science
Is the James Webb Space Telescope really 'breaking' cosmology?
Not long after the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) began its Science operations, astronomers announced that they had discovered galaxies in the early universe that were far too large, bright and full of stars for their age. While headlines around the world claimed that these galaxies were "breaking" our understanding of the Big Bang, the truth is much more nuanced — and much more interesting.
The Big Bang theory is our general picture of the History of the universe, starting in its deep past, when the cosmos was much smaller, hotter and denser than it is today. This model, initially developed in the early 20th century, has survived a battery of observational tests and is extremely good at explaining a variety of cosmological observations, including the redshifting of light from distant galaxies, the appearance of leftover radiation in the form of the cosmic microwave background, the abundances of light elements, and the evolution of galaxies and larger structures.
While the Big Bang theory can't say for certain which galaxies will appear where, it can talk about probabilities. For example, cosmologists can say roughly how many small galaxies, how many medium galaxies and how many large galaxies should appear in a given volume at a certain age of the universe. But until JWST, we did not have direct observational access to the earliest stages of galactic evolution — something the telescope was explicitly designed to study.
In 2022, astronomers announced that they had found extremely distant galaxies that were surprisingly, weirdly large. They had measured the redshift of the galaxies to be over 16, implying that these galaxies existed just 200 million to 250 million years after the Big Bang. Yet they were gigantic and appeared to be fully formed, with spiral arms and everything.
Related: 'The early universe is nothing like we expected': James Webb telescope reveals 'new understanding' of how galaxies formed at cosmic dawn
These galaxies seemed far outside the expectations of the Big Bang theory; they were like finding teenagers in a kindergarten classroom. So what was going on?
Bending cosmology
Cue the brazen headlines proclaiming the death of the Big Bang theory. But those stories left out a crucial detail: Astronomers estimated the redshift of those galaxies through a technique known as photometry, which is incredibly uncertain. A full evaluation of the ability of those galaxies to "break" cosmology would have to wait for a more precise measurement of their redshift, and hence their age.
-
Science10h ago
Why is everything in space always moving?
-
Science21h ago
NASA discovers planet-wide electric field around Earth that's shooting bits of our atmosphere into space
-
Science21h ago
'Catastrophic' SpaceX Starship explosion tore a hole in the atmosphere last year in 1st-of-its-kind event, Russian scientists reveal
-
Science1d ago
Scientists confirm that most of the universe is 'darkness and nothing more'
-
Science1d ago
AI uncovers the universe's 'settings' with unprecedented precision, and it could help to resolve the Hubble tension
-
Science1d ago
Giant underwater avalanche decimated Atlantic seafloor 60,000 years ago, 1st-of-its-kind map reveals
-
Science1d ago
Al Naslaa rock: Saudi Arabia's enigmatic sandstone block that's split perfectly down the middle
-
Science2d ago
SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket grounded for 2nd time in 2 months following explosive landing failure