Panel Splits 3/2: Friday Evening Reo Hatate Verdict

The SFA’s Key Match Incident (KMI) panel has ruled that Reo Hatate should have been sent off during Celtic’s 2-0 victory over Kilmarnock last weekend.

The decision stems from an incident late in the match, with Hatate sliding in late on Killie’s Liam Donnelly. Referee Nick Walsh opted against showing the Japanese midfielder a red card, and VAR did not recommend an on-field review. As a result, Hatate completed the match without further sanction.

However, upon review, the KMI panel reached a 3-2 decision in favour of deeming the referee’s call incorrect. The majority argued that the challenge “endangered the safety of the opponent” and warranted a dismissal. The two dissenting panel members expressed doubts over whether the tackle met the threshold of being a “clear and obvious” error, highlighting the fine margins involved.

Our Verdict

Hatate’s tackle has sparked debate, with many questioning whether it truly merited a sending-off. While the midfielder appeared to pull out of the challenge at the last moment, the panel’s ruling indicates that intent was irrelevant given the perceived danger to the opposing player. In our opinion, we couldn’t have many complaints if he was sent off.

The match itself saw Celtic navigate a tough test at Rugby Park, where Brendan Rodgers’ side eventually secured a vital three points to reclaim top spot in the Scottish Premiership. Goals from Callum McGregor and Nicolas Kuhn sealed the win.

Celtic’s Packed Schedule Ahead

The Hoops are currently using the international break to recharge ahead of a gruelling fixture list. From November 23rd, Celtic face a relentless schedule, playing twice a week through to mid-January as they juggle domestic and European commitments.

With matches coming thick and fast, Rodgers will be keen to keep his squad disciplined and fully fit for the challenges ahead. Whether the SFA’s verdict on Hatate impacts Celtic in future decisions remains to be seen.